A Conversation with Dr. Spinuzzi: The Power of Persuasion at Work
Effective communication and persuasion are essential to navigating today’s complex workplaces. Through decades of research on workplace communication, entrepreneurship, and organizational life, Dr. Spinuzzi has explored how people collaborate, solve problems, and influence decision-making. At The University of Texas at Austin’s Human Dimensions of Organizations (HDO) program, these insights extend into the classroom, where students draw on their own professional experiences to rethink workplace challenges and discover new ways forward. The following interview with HDO Program Manager, Heather Moreau, discusses his research, approach to teaching persuasion, and what makes the HDO program a meaningful experience for both students and faculty.
1. Your work has taken you across rhetoric, workplace communication, and organizational life. What questions or problems are you most interested in exploring these days?
One project is my research on startups — I just published a textbook on entrepreneurship communication and am working on a scholarly book based on the research I’ve done for the past 12 years. Startups are such an interesting case of persuasion because not only do they have to sharpen their argument, they have a lot of different stakeholders that don’t always see things the same way. So startups have to constantly pitch, they have to listen to stakeholder feedback, and they have to figure out a path forward that is based in part on that feedback. In the early phases, they are constantly honing their value proposition and considering their product, market, and organization. It’s a complex process, and watching it happen is fascinating.
Another project is a cultural-historical understanding of genre, which we can think of as a text type. When we start to use a type of text — like a pitch deck, a recommendation report, a resume, or even a grocery list — we’re learning how to think about the activity in which we use that text type. Over time, we get better at making pitch decks, reports, and so forth; our efforts begin to support our activity more effectively. But we also get better at connecting them to other text types. For instance, part of writing a good resume is understanding what information a prospective employer needs from it, and that entails understanding how they will compare it to their job ad, your cover letter, and other texts. I’ve been working with genre theory for about 30 years, but I’d like to rethink parts of it by applying recent insights from cultural-historical theory. Some of these insights were discussed in my 2025 book, but I think there’s a lot more to say here.
2. How does that research make its way into what and how you teach HDO students?
It’s a huge part of what I teach. In 1997, I spent a summer as a graduate intern at Schlumberger’s Austin Product Center, where I observed software engineers at work and asked them questions about how they worked. By the end of the summer, I knew two things: (1) I wanted to live in Austin, and (2) I wanted to keep conducting qualitative research in workplaces. I was fascinated by the problems people encounter at work and how inventively they solve these problems. Since then, I’ve studied the work of traffic safety engineers, telecommunications workers, freelancers, search engine marketers, people in coworking spaces, and startup founders — and I’ve benefited by reading many, many other studies of work.
These studies have taught me a deep respect for how people work and how they put together systems for solving problems — and that carries over to the HDO MA, where our students all have their own expertise. We all really do learn from each other. My focus is on giving them concepts, vocabularies, and methodologies so that they can see their own work in a new light, think about it differently, and try out new ways to solve their problems. Overall, I think it’s worked out well!
3. You teach Persuasion and Argumentation in the HDO master’s program. What do you most want students to understand about persuasion by the end of the course?
It’s common to think of persuasion as something we do to an audience. But I want our students to think of persuasion as something we do with an audience. If I’m presenting a recommendation report, a proposal, or a startup pitch to someone, I need to understand what they value — what they need to get out of the interaction — and consider how we can develop a solution that works for all of us. Doing that doesn’t just involve writing or talking, it involves a lot of listening and dialogue, often among different groups who are trying to achieve different goals. Mapping out those interests, and holding dialogues about how to reconcile them, is vital to consequential decision-making. So we read case studies about persuasion, try out different heuristics for holding dialogues, and end with a live pitch whose focus is not just to persuade, but to elicit helpful Q&A.
4. What do people tend to misunderstand about persuasion, especially in organizational settings?
People tend to think persuasion is one-and-done — like a transaction in which you’re just trying to get someone to sign on the dotted line. Maybe that works in some situations, like in real estate sales, where the buyer and seller make the transaction and never talk again. But in organizational settings, you have to see people day after day, and persuasion is part of that ongoing relationship that you build over time. So that means that you have to develop a deep understanding of what people value, both personally and institutionally, and how to take those things into account.
5. Can you give an example of a situation at work where someone might have a strong idea but struggle to persuade others to act on it? What makes the difference?
Sure. One example that we’ve seen a lot recently is that companies spend resources on AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Claude, or CoPilot, then encourage their employees to “use AI more” — but without much guidance beyond that. The problem is that AI can be really good at some things, but really terrible at others, and it always requires a human being to ultimately take responsibility. So employees worry that sprinkling AI on everything will introduce errors into their work, disrupt trust with others, and maybe even result in proprietary information becoming part of the AI’s training data. So employees often find themselves wanting to push back, but they may not know exactly what to ask for. When that happens, it’s easy for management to dismiss their concerns as being simply reactionary.
In a situation like this, I’d suggest taking the time to develop a solid proposal argument that acknowledges management’s goals, shows why the current AI initiative doesn’t reach them, and provides a well-considered alternate plan that does reach those goals. Doing that effectively means developing a deep understanding of those goals, perhaps even quoting them, and showing how those goals won’t be reached by the current solution — then proposing an alternate approach with a better chance of working, and with a reasonable timeline and budget. This approach acknowledges the audience’s objectives and provides an actual way to realize them.
6. What tends to surprise HDO students most when they begin studying persuasion and argumentation more deeply?
On the first day, HDO students already know that persuasion isn’t simply black and white. But I think they are surprised by how much thought has been put into aspects of persuasion. We begin with classical figures like Aristotle and touch on a few other major aspects of rhetorical analysis, and this gives them a conceptual language for talking about it. Suddenly, rather than saying “this sounds logical,” they’re able to examine an argument using Toulmin structure and identify the warrants (assumptions) on which it rests. By the end of the first session, they can confidently identify claims, evidence, and warrants as well as rhetorical appeals, and this vocabulary means that they can have more precise conversations about what’s happening in a given argument.
7. You have taught HDO students for many years and been awarded Professor of the Year three times. What keeps you coming back to the HDO classroom, and what do you find most rewarding about teaching HDO students?
What I have loved about HDO from the beginning is that our MA students are midcareer professionals — so they have all developed expertise in their own fields and can speak confidently about that expertise. They’re fully formed human beings with a lot of knowledge. That means that when we’re talking about a concept or method, people can bring in their own experiences to contextualize these, and sometimes they even push back against our readings or my lectures. That’s great, since it becomes the starting point for a deeper conversation. At the end of each class, I’ve learned more too, and I’ve likely written down ideas and book recommendations so I can read more about them later.
More than that, HDO MA students are often in the program because they are trying to solve a problem related to their work or industry. They are looking for conceptual and methodological tools to help them get there. So it’s just amazing when we can bring the expertise of the room to bear on their problem. Each professor has their corner of expertise, but so does each student, and by the end of the program, each student has soaked up a lot of this expertise in relation to their problem, resulting in a unique mix that draws from the best ideas across the liberal arts
8. You also serve the program in the role of HDO’s graduate advisor. Are there particular projects or research questions that have stayed with you, and why?
Yes, we’ve had a really incredible range of projects. When we first designed this program, we decided that rather than writing a thesis, MA students would produce a capstone. And that’s because we recognized that a traditional MA thesis was too narrow for the different problems people were trying to solve. That was a good decision.
We’ve had many capstones that followed a traditional research focus — for instance, capstones have used interviews, surveys, and observations to explore how remote workers experience mentoring differently, what employees think of incentive systems, and why companies insist on return-to-office mandates. Others have surveyed the literature on a particular concept or problem, such as hate speech, compassion, or leadership. And then we have some really out-of-the-box capstones, such as a card game that was developed to help people explore metaphors at work, a documentary about a nonprofit, and a proposal that one student wrote to her organization about changing a policy.
9. What do you think HDO offers experienced professionals that can be difficult to get from professional experience alone?
As working professionals, HDO MA students often know what does and doesn’t work in their workplaces and industries. But they may not know how to describe it for others, where to find more information on how others handled these problems differently, or why one approach is better than another. As they take HDO classes, they discover concepts, methodologies, and an entry point into the vast research literature. They begin reading theory and research, and they discover that a lot of people have spent a lot of time thinking about problems like the ones they face. That is, a lot of that conceptual work has already been done, and they can find it and use it to address their capstone problem. More importantly, now they know how to handle the next problem and how to solve completely new ones.
10. What advice would you give someone considering HDO who is wondering whether this is the right moment in their career to pursue it?
If you’re a midcareer professional with a lot of experience in your industry, but you’re struggling with a problem that you’re having trouble getting your head around — or if everyone else seems to accept an answer to that problem that you know is too simple — or if you are getting conflicting information and you’re not sure how to sort through it — consider HDO.
If you’re on the cusp of a big career change and want to retool yourself, or if everyone is saying you should get an MBA but it’s not people-focused enough for you, or if you feel like your career has a ceiling — consider HDO.
